Subaru, Mazda, BMW, Honda & Lexus Top Best Brands Rated by Consumer Reports

The best cars on the road are largely made by Japanese automakers, according to the latest Brand Report Card rankings from Consumer Reports (CR), the nonprofit consumer research, testing, and advocacy organization. Six Japanese brands place among the top-10 in the rankings, which reveal which automakers are producing the most well-performing, safe, and reliable vehicles based on CR’s independent testing and member surveys.

Subaru climbed two positions to reclaim the number one spot on this year’s list. Mazda is in second place, followed by BMW, Honda, Lexus, Audi, Porsche, Mini, Toyota, and Infiniti.

“Brands that rise to the top tend to have the most consistent performance across their model lineups,” said Jake Fisher, senior director of automotive testing at Consumer Reports. “For mainstream brands like Subaru, Mazda, and Honda to have such a strong showing is remarkable. For consumers, it shows that you don’t need to splurge on a luxury brand to get a safe, satisfying, and reliable car.”

Domestic automakers did not fare as well in this year’s CR rankings. Buick is the highest-charting U.S. brand, sliding out of the top-10 to eleventh place. Chrysler is close behind (13th place), while Dodge is midpack (16th place), and the remaining domestics are all in the bottom half of the rankings. Jeep, which had reliability issues with the Gladiator pickup truck, comes in dead last.

Tesla dropped seven spots to 23rd overall, mainly due to the difficult-to-use yoke steering wheel the automaker introduced into its Model S and Model X, which lowered their road-test scores. The Model 3 remains the lone Tesla model that is CR recommended.

As part of the nonprofit organization’s focus on reducing the impact of emissions on the environment, CR once again included in this year’s Brand Report Card the number of CR-tested vehicles  in the brand’s line-up that earned the Green Choice designation, marking them as among the cleanest, lowest-emitting passenger vehicles. While Toyota (9th overall) doesn’t produce a dedicated battery electric vehicle yet, its numerous hybrid and plug-in hybrid choices helped it lead all brands with 11 Green Choice models.

“Today, there are so many new options and so much groundbreaking technology in cars and trucks. What hasn’t changed is the need for trustworthy information so consumers can navigate through these choices,” said Marta L. Tellado, President and CEO of Consumer Reports. “At Consumer Reports, we’re committed to making sure the options serve consumers’ best interests, particularly when it comes to safety and sustainability.”

In total, 32 brands are included in CR’s 2022 Brand Report Card. The organization conducts more than 50 science-based tests on every vehicle it evaluates, including braking, handling, comfort, convenience, safety, and fuel economy. CR then determines the Overall Score—a combination of predicted reliability, and owner satisfaction based on member surveys, and CR’s hands-on analysis that includes road performance, key safety features, and crash-test results, if available—for each model tested. The brands are then ranked by averaging the Overall Scores of their respective models to reveal the best and worst.

CR buys all of its test cars anonymously from dealers and does not accept free samples from automakers for any of its ratings or evaluations. CR’s testers drive a total of 500,000 miles annually in the vehicles it evaluates, which is the equivalent of circling the Earth twenty times.

Top Brands

  1. Subaru
  2. Mazda
  3. BMW
  4. Honda
  5. Lexus
  6. Audi
  7. Porsche
  8. Mini
  9. Toyota
  10. Infiniti
  11. Buick
  12. Acura
  13. Chrysler
  14. Hyundai
  15. Nissan
  16. Dodge
  17. Volkswagen
  18. Kia
  19. Genesis
  20. Volvo
  21. Cadillac
  22. Ford
  23. Tesla
  24. Chevrolet
  25. Mercedes-Benz
  26. Lincoln
  27. Jaguar
  28. Alfa Romeo
  29. Land Rover
  30. Mitsubishi
  31. GMC
  32. JeepLast year, Mazda was on top. BMW was No. 2, and Subaru was No. 3. Jake Fisher, senior director of automotive testing at Consumer Reports, said the report takes a holistic approach, in an effort to encompass everything about the ownership experience. Vehicle testing, surveys, and performance on crash tests all come into play.